I had a serious case of 'wha?' not just in that thread, but in the one before. I feel that I ought to leave one last comment; but I also feel that if I jump in right now, I don't think it would work.

I have a feeling of having stepped sideways into another universe again. I don't remember this poster as being so belligerent and quarrelsome, or rather, I seem to have blocked those episodes from my mind, because the one you referred to stuck vaguely in my mind (but not who initiated it); and I now remember having said something in relation to the scene discussed in a previous thread that had boiled down to 'this is bland, you need telling detail' which he refuted furiously at the time and now repeated as an insight he gained himself, and I was equally puzzled by his demeanour then.

People are seriously weird sometimes.